Ethology
is the science
that studies
behaviors of a species
under natural situations. Therefore,
it studies instinctive
and non-instinctive behaviors
that are typical
of a species.
Dog
whispering is a training technique
based on canine ethology. So, it takes into account those behaviors that
are natural
in dogs, but usually ignore
the principles
of learning theories.
The fundamental
premise of dog whispering
is that
the owner should
become the
leader of the
pack. This
is also
known as the
theory or paradigm of the alpha dog.
According to the alpha
dog paradigm, dogs establish
dominance hierarchies
in the pack. Thus, you should
achieve the higher hierarchy, the alpha
dog status, in
order to maintain a good relationship with your dog.
Though it is not clear when the paradigm of the alpha dog appeared, it is
well known that it gained popularity in the eighties.
Jan Fennell
and Cesar Millan
are two of the
most famous practitioners of dog whispering. The latter is perhaps the most famed trainer at these
days, because of his show "The Dog Whisperer" broadcasted
by National Geographic.
Some authors say that dog whispering is based
on scientific studies of
wolf packs. Others say the technique was
developed after studying the social
behavior of dogs
for several years.
Unfortunately,
there are several non-standardized
variants of this
technique. Besides,
some of the technique variants seem to be based only on popular beliefs
and not on
real studies about dog behavior.
Dog whispering
by itself is useless to teach
obedience commands. For that reason, many trainers don't accept it as real training technique. Moreover, it is also frequent that
practitioners of this technique don't consider themselves as dog trainers. Instead, they
claim they are
people who can communicate with dogs by a deep
understanding of dog
behavior and proper body language.
Dog whispering advocates claim that the technique
provides a natural
way to communicate with dogs. Some of these people also
tend to use non-violent procedures. However, the degree of violence is highly
variable and depends on the
method used by the trainer.
Detractors claim that there is a lack of solid arguments in this technique. They also claim that dog whispering is based on popular
beliefs, which
could be true
for several of
its variants.
Same detractors usually question the alpha dog paradigm and argue that there's no need for a model based on dominance hierarchies.
Biologists Raymond and
Lorna Coppinger are among the few people who
carried out extensive scientific studies on social behavior and
evolution of dogs. Their studies reject the paradigm of the alpha dog, and these
scientists say that
wolves and dogs have very different behavior repertoires. Therefore, studies on the behavior of wolves shouldn't be
useful for a better understanding of dog's behavior.
Perhaps further studies on
canine ethology could lead to a better understanding of dog behavior.
Meanwhile, most dog whispering variants can't provide clear and precise guidelines for dog training; even when there are some really successful "dog
whisperers" like Cesar Millan and Jan Fennell.
Rodrigo Trigosso is a biologist and professional dog trainer.
His website
http://www.dog-training-tutorial.com provides great info on canine training and behavior.